Post Location of business scandal CEO steps down from roles after big miscarriage of justice is laid naked

Post Location of business scandal CEO steps down from roles after big miscarriage of justice is laid naked

by Posted on

Former Post Location of business CEO Paula Vennells has left roles within the church, Morrisons and Dunelm after postmasters’ convictions had been overturned within the Courtroom of Enchantment

Karl Flinders

By

Published: 26 Apr 2021 10: 59

Former Post Location of business CEO Paula Vennells has stepped down from two business roles and as an accomplice Church of England minister after the Courtroom of Enchantment dominated that the organisation she ran for seven years from 2012 had prosecuted innocent other folks.

Vennells’ roles on the boards of outlets Morrisons and Dunelm and on the Church of England become untenable following the damning judgments.

Final week, the Courtroom of Enchantment overturned the convictions of 39 passe subpostmasters who the government-owned Post Location of business had blamed for accounting shortfalls. Some had been despatched to penal complex and the lives of people and their households had been ruined.

The entire selection of convictions overturned thus some distance is 45, with six others overturned at Southawk Crown Courtroom in December, and there’ll be extra. The Felony Cases Review Commission (CCRC), which referred potentially the most up to date cases to the Courtroom of Enchantment, is for the time being reviewing 22 extra cases and the Scottish CCRC is five.

Bigger than 700 other folks had been prosecuted in accordance with evidence from the Post Location of business’s Horizon IT machine, which has been proved to be maintain errors.

Vennells left the Post Location of business in 2019 true sooner than a unhealthy High Courtroom judgment that slammed the management of the organisation that punished subpostmasters for mistakes made by its web pc machine. She took better than £400,000 in pay and bonuses with her. 

Vennells left her role as chair at Imperial College Healthcare NHS Have confidence in December following revelations about her role within the Horizon scandal, however remained in her other roles.

Nonetheless the Courtroom of Enchantment judgment elevated the pressure by ruling that the prosecutions of subpostmasters had been better than incompetence on the Post Location of business’s part, however had been performed despite the Post Location of business gleaming that they’re going to now now not gather a aesthetic trial. The Post Location of business had admitted that it wrongly prosecuted subpostmasters on the grounds that the computer evidence worn in prosecutions become as soon as potentially unreliable (“Limb 1”), however after Paul Marshall of Cornerstone Barristers insisted on the suppose being pursued, an additional limb become as soon as licensed by the court docket as an controversial ground for allure.

“Limb 2”, as it is known, meant the Post Location of business knew it become as soon as now now not which that you just can factor in for subpostmasters to maintain a aesthetic trial however prosecuted them anyway, which become as soon as an “affront to the public judgment of appropriate and unsuitable,” in accordance with the CCRC – or, because the Courtroom of Enchantment mentioned in its judgment, “an affront to the judgment of appropriate and unsuitable of the court docket”.  In attain, here is behavior that undermines the prison justice machine or public self assurance in it.

The 39 convictions that had been overturned had been quashed on both grounds. This throws the spotlight on the Post Location of business management on story of it is no longer a case of mere incompetence that resulted in the wrongful prosecutions, however deliberate Post Location of business technique.

Marshall insisted on the court docket hearing the Limb 2 argument and the Courtroom of Enchantment finally agreed to listen to it despite opposition from the Post Location of business within the March 2021 allure.

Marshall mentioned that with out that 2d ground for allure, Vennells could per chance maintain mentioned the selections to prosecute had been merely operational errors and nothing to attain with her. “What the Courtroom of Enchantment decision on Limb 2 does is suppose your total course of prosecutions that had been interested by Horizon disorders and the Post Location of business’s total technique around them, for which she become as soon as within the destroy accountable, had been an abuse of the courts’ course of,” he mentioned.

The Post Location of business become as soon as made responsive to attainable pc errors over a long time. Pc Weekly first printed the scandal in 2009, with the reviews of seven subpostmasters. Nonetheless the Post Location of business, led by Vennells from 2012 to 2019, consistently denied that there had been any errors within the Horizon machine (survey timeline below of Pc Weekly articles since 2009).

Even in 2015, after an self reliant document on Horizon by forensic accounting agency Second Glance stumbled on excessive complications within the machine, the Post Location of business peaceful denied their existence.

That twelve months, the Post Location of business’s then head of communications, Price Davies, wrote this about regarding the Post Location of business-commissioned document within the Subspaceonline journal, which become as soon as despatched to subpostmasters: “A lot of the reporting is designed, as reporting continuously is, to most up to date a image which appears alarming: it does now now not on the different hand replicate the actuality of the suppose, which is about a blueprint from which that you just can learn about or survey on the TV.”

Davies also wrote on the time: “Unfortunately the forensic accountants maintain also repeated allegations which could per chance successfully be now now not supported by the info. We won’t no doubt beef up their findings on these capabilities – and likewise that you just can now now not ask us to attain otherwise.”

This denial mirrored the Post Location of business’s stance on Horizon’s complications for about a years. Vennells become as soon as responsible of the organisation and therefore accountable for this.

Former subpostmaster Jo Hamilton, who had her prison conviction overturned, mentioned the victims of the scandal could per chance maintain had their lives wait on nearly decade within the past if Vennells had now now not missed their claims and reviews that Horizon become as soon as potentially at fault for the accounting shortfalls.

“From the disclosure in court docket, it is obvious she knew nearly a decade within the past what become as soon as going down and yet she chose to web and complex it out,” mentioned Hamilton. “She allowed two High Courtroom trials to switch forward at a notice of tons of of thousands and thousands of pounds and glorious when it become as soon as sure we had been successful did she step down from her Post place of job role. We would maintain had our lives wait on 10 years within the past.

“By taking on many senior roles in various areas, including the Cupboard Location of business, it is obvious she has no real compass at all.”

In 2019, Vennells become as soon as awarded a CBE for products and services to the Post Location of business and charity. There are calls within the Home of Commons and amongst the public for her to be stripped of this.

Insist material Continues Below


Learn extra on IT for retail and logistics

Learn Extra